Definitely the weakest track on the album - it's not bad exactly, just overshadowed by everything else. It also feels slightly too familiar, like a reheated 'In Your Lap'. A little bit of Manzur goes a long way, and I'm not sure I want too many of this style of song.
To me it's very similar to In Your Lap: a po-faced and meandering piano dullfest that goes nowhere neither musically nor lyrically. Up to this point Dog is a very strong and an adventurous album, but this and Secret of Music make for a very weak third act, mercifully redeemed by Hurling Days. To me this is the worst track on Dog, since Secret of Music at least has an admirable devil may care attitude to it.