No, I don't think it would. In fact, it's trite and insulting. I'd say above all else including musical output Johnny's managed to become a happy and well-adjusted human. Can we honestly say that about Morrissey... especially these last few years? YOU LOVE MORRISSEY ABOVE ALL ELSE!!! Message received loud and clear.
Totally agree. While I have found Marr's solo stuff quite anodyne and boring, he seems like a content middle-aged man. Perhaps that's why he doesn't really feel the need to stretch and suffer for his art. I for one can't really begrudge him that. Calling him a broken man is just pathetic and insulting, especially coming from somebody who comes across as a disagreeable fanatic.