Johan de Witt
Senior Member
So with all this debate about the GH tracklisting let us see if we actually have bought/will buy (in the case of GH) any of them.
Which of these Smiths/Morrissey reissue/repackage albums do you own/will you buy?
- Thread starter Johan de Witt
- Start date
Vauxhall95
I Know It's Over...
I purchased "Bona Drag" and "World of Morrissey" both used. I purchased "My Early Burglary Years" new. I passed on Rhino's "Best of" collection and will pass on the upcoming "Greatest Hits".
I'll purchase the two new tracks via download, but I will not be purchasing a "Greatest Hits" album. I already own not only the albums the songs were originally released on, but the CD singles for the vast majority of the songs too.
nugz
SUPAHSTAR!
for Smiths I have Louder than Bombs and The World Won't listen. I dont own any of those "greatest hits" or "singles" comps. for Moz I have Bona Drag, World of Morrissey and Early Burglary Years. I never listen to World of Morrissey though. I dont have any "Best of" or "Greatest hits" Moz cds. and i def won't be buying this upcoming one.
jeniphir
Doing Very Well
I am not what my record-collecting ex would call a "Completist" when it comes to owning every conceivable permutation of an artist's work (particularly when there are no new versions of the same old songs on repackaged product). Of those, I only have My Early Burglary Years. I will prolly buy the CD single of People Throw Up when the new greatest comes out, and/or get the new song/s off iTunes, but won't splash out for the CD.
--jeniphir
--jeniphir
Last edited:
Radio Berlin
moz is ♥
I have everything that's available today, and I will get the new GH as soon as humanly possible 
i have all in the list and have purchased BONA DRAG like 11 times in my life...
whether it be that i played them to death, or gave them away to people when they say they've never heard of morrissey, or because i cannot stand seeing MORRISSEY in the used section.
whether it be that i played them to death, or gave them away to people when they say they've never heard of morrissey, or because i cannot stand seeing MORRISSEY in the used section.
nugz
SUPAHSTAR!
ha, no offense, but thats just ridiculous and a little insane.
Bluebirds
Well-Known Member
Johan de Witt
Senior Member
Johan the question is though will you be in France?
Yes, Wille be in Lille.
Looking forward to seeing you there.
Johan de Witt
Senior Member
So nearly half of us are going to buy it, and this could increase when the album is actually released.
More people will buy this then The Best Of Morrissey, which is not surprising considering GH has 2 new songs and The Best Of... had none.
I just don't remember the same amount of criticism when The Best Of was released.
More people will buy this then The Best Of Morrissey, which is not surprising considering GH has 2 new songs and The Best Of... had none.
I just don't remember the same amount of criticism when The Best Of was released.
Vauxhall95
I Know It's Over...
Well, timing for one. When The Best Of was released, wasn't it during the seven year drought? So, I think we were amazed anything was being released.
Also, I think it is the inclusion of the new tracks. They simply serve to raise the dander of his core fan base because we all collect nearly everything he releases, but this just reeks of a cash grab because there is no way anyone here buys the Greatest Hits without the inclusion of the new tracks, and then you're back to having to pay $15 for two unreleased songs. Not cool...
I didn't buy it until I read on Passions that two of the songs were slightly different versions, and one ("Lost"), I didn't have yet. So yeah, even if the Grayest Hits has even one slight change to one song, I'd buy it.
Vauxhall95
I Know It's Over...
sistasheila
tjekket
my first smiths cd was "singles" and it really beats the best of 1 and 2 by miles cause the best of was really trhrown together..they surely had adviced some trainee in their company to put songs together and it was by far the imprudentliest compilation ever ..moz and marr wasnt involved in best of 1 and 2 and you could tell
but singles is great and great for a first contact with the band starts with hand in glove and ends with there is alight (even though light wasnt a official single)
you could see that they arent not only a album band but a singles band as well and both of them confirm and spoke a lot about that
the singles they released mean as much to them as the albums
i have world of morrissey because of the nonreleased stuff and decided angainst suedehead-best of cause world of only cost me 4 euro...and uedehead about 14.99 so "orld of was"the one i chooseand my ealy
burlgary years which cost me about 6-8 euro so i saw no need to buy "suedehead" since all the non releasedsongs were also on
world of and burlgary
but singles is great and great for a first contact with the band starts with hand in glove and ends with there is alight (even though light wasnt a official single)
you could see that they arent not only a album band but a singles band as well and both of them confirm and spoke a lot about that
the singles they released mean as much to them as the albums
i have world of morrissey because of the nonreleased stuff and decided angainst suedehead-best of cause world of only cost me 4 euro...and uedehead about 14.99 so "orld of was"the one i chooseand my ealy
burlgary years which cost me about 6-8 euro so i saw no need to buy "suedehead" since all the non releasedsongs were also on
world of and burlgary
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
