sparacus
Member
i don't think you have to worry about 38 million poles coming to live in the uk.
I'd imagine that most want to. Why stay in Poland when you can come here?
i don't think you have to worry about 38 million poles coming to live in the uk.
this is the same argument they used to get women to stay home and not work. "women are taking jobs away from men." first it was based on sex, now race. it may be a huge generalisation but it is also the general picture. university qualified poles are coming here to do jobs which they are over qualified for. they also do not set the rate at which they are paid. if employers are illegally paying below standard rates should you blame the victim?
simple solution, the uk should leave the eu and not allow any european to enter for work without being properly vetted for specific positions. don't blame one nation in a whole range of countries this rule applies to.
so a rich migrant is a welcomed migrant?
I'd imagine that most want to. Why stay in Poland when you can come here?
But there hasn't been a mass flood of immigrants and there's nothing that suggest it should.
Why isn't skill entirely relevant? Many who are young and well educated only work abroad for a short period of let's say ten years and then they return home. There has been some competition for the domestic Universities plus their home country, which long has been isolated, has got experience from how other countries work.
I think we should do what i think they do in america and australia, you have to actually have some purpose be able to do a job.
I can tell you don't live in the UK. There must have been other factors in the Sweden-Poland situation, is all I can say..
Qualifications aren't relevant for two reasons. Firstly, with Poland being in the EU, it isn't only qualified people who can move around countries, it's the unqualified too, such as labourers, or semi-qualified (tradesmen). Lowering wages where they don't actually 'take' the jobs of UK nationals. Secondly, back to the self-interest argument I was detailing my reply to Jeane. In an ideal world there should be roughly as many openings in Poland for qualified people (per capita) as in the UK. This would represent then a 'fair deal' for the UK and existing members of the EU before Poland joined (our workers being allowed to take as many positions over there as others could come here to get). Of course, we don't live in an ideal world and certain disparities can be expected between nations (as already existed before the eastern european nations joined) but it's when the situation is so hopelessly unbalanced that the problem becomes acute.
but you are trying to justify discriminating against a particular race based on nothing else but they are from a particular country
with logic such as "they are taking our jobs" something that is not reflected in the statistics. ......if a uk national is losing out on a position, merely based on wage alone, then this is not correct. but mainly this is not the case . reports over and over again have indicated that poles are taking the jobs that otherwise will not be filled. this week, there was a report on the bbc speaking with bus companies in manchester who were saying that without the poles, they would have to restrict their services because they would have no drivers. and they were paid the standard rate. .... you can keep repeating that poles are taking the jobs off uk nationals but this is simply not backed up with the statistics.
the "taking our jobs" excuse is one that is repeated over and over throughout the years, changing it's focus with whomever is flavour of the month at that time.
of course, every nation should be able to determine it's policies on employment and immigration. the uk chose this. this has not been enforced on this nation.
you do realise the uk is benefitting from the poles coming here don't you? if not culturally, then ecomonically, namely, the polish pound?
its growing ecomony will only benefit the eu in the long term.
Mass immigration is incompatable with true socialism. It is used by business to keep wages low. Poles are often willing to work for extremely low wages
I certainly agree with you that lowering wages is a problem but it hasn't been as large as many predicted. However it should not be tolerated. It should be the skill and not the prices that counts.
Finally for me, getting back to Moz, the fact that he is the son of immigrants himself (and I'm 2nd generation Irish too) makes it even worst. His parents came here for a better life and to give him a better life. Now he wants to stop others stopped from doing the same? Pull up the ladder? Very sad.
Morrissey did not say "pull up the ladder". He wants "sensible" management of immigration. There's a big difference.
That's not a very convincing example, though. We have a very low unemployment rate here, relatively speaking. Last's month's unemployment rate for NYC is 5.3%. I doubt that a sizeable portion of those unemployed citizens tried to get jobs as bartenders, only to be priced out by immigrant labor.
'Sensible management' still means that he would deny the same right to some that his parents had.
'Sensible management' still means that he would deny the same right to some that his parents had. He alludes to exactly this in the first interview in fact but then goes back on it later on. I think the fella is very confused on this really.
He doesn't explain his views on English or British culture very well, bar not hearing English accents in Knightsbridge or wherever. Again I'm 2nd generation Irish working class and I regard myself as British/English, like him, but I don't think 'Britain' is disappearing at all. And I live in an area with historically high immigration.
It is true that multiculturalism is problematic and has caused segregation but that is the fault of multiculturalism, which has been handed down from above, (probably to deliberately divide workers) and not the fault of immigration or immigrants. Most immigrants voluntarily assimilate or somewhere down the line their children do. Moz is a prime example of that. He isn't any less British because his parents were Irish. So I just don't get where he is coming from.
Firstly i'd like to say hello to everyone as this is my first post here
I think Morrissey has been set up here by the N.M.E.(i was at Madstock in 92), but from what i've read here, it seems he's only answered the questions he was asked. What was he meant to say? It's the truth what he's said, and he hasn't even lived here for years and he's noticed the sudden change in Britain over the last few years. Anyone would have to be blind to think that there isn't a problem with the influx of migrants into this country.
Do you listen to John Gaunt each day on Talk Sport (10am - 1pm)? You sound like a regular contributor (usually London taxi drivers)
No one says anything about thousands of Brits now living in Spain, shafting the local Spanish culture, reading the Sun everyday and watching Sky Sports whilst saying 'Landan ain't Landan anymore, to many bladdy foreigners init'.
The British Empire has done more to mess around with other nations cultures than any other over the past 400-200 years, so we are getting a taste of our own medicine and it dosn't taste nice does it? We reap what we sow.
Jukebox Jury